Egg Custard Tarts
I just wanted to say thankyou for all your kind and encouraging comments on my last post.
________________________________
One of Phill’s favourite desserts are those little egg custard tarts you can buy from supermarkets. They are beautifully yellow in a little pastry case, with nutmeg sprinkled on top and they are usually delicious. However, we bought some last week and while we were eating them, we realised there was just something lacking. I found them to taste watery. We were disappointed and I decided I was going to try to make my own.
After a quick internet search, I discovered most egg custard recipes called for nine eggs and I only had four on hand. Luckily, I found a recipe that asked for three, so that’s the one I went with. It seemed simple enough, with only a few ingredients: three eggs, two cups of milk, two tablespoons of caster sugar and a cap of vanilla essence (I used extract).
For the pastry I used Pampas pastry cases, bought from the freezer section of my supermarket:
They require cooking at 160 for fan forced, or 180 for regular oven, for ten minutes, then allow to cool. The thing I noticed about them was how shallow they were. Since my custard mixture was quite thin (perhaps I should have somehow made it thicken?) I couldn’t fit much of it into the tart cases because it would quickly overflow. Is that what I get for being lazy and buying pre-made tarts? Perhaps.
Straight out of the packet, they’re quite yellow and raw. It’s recommended that you leave the alfoil cases on while cooking – I guess this might be partly so they won’t collapse? I’m so paranoid about these fragile cases – even while at the shops, I was willing the cashier to pack them separately so nothing would squash them (and he did, thankyou!) and the only casualty was one with a tiny bit of the crust missing – nothing too severe and it was obviously damage that had occured while in the bag.
After cooking, they are paler with a lovely crisp crust – YUM! I could eat them straight away, but I had to be patient and let them cool before filling them with the lovely egg custard. You can see in the photo how shallow they are. I had literally just started pouring when they began to overflow through the dimples in the crust, dammit.
I realised I had a lot of mixture left over, so I grabbed a sheet of puff pastry from the freezer and a quiche dish from the cupboard and made another pie. I realised we’d be having egg custard tarts for a few days (not that there’s anything wrong with that!). I pre-cooked the puff pastry for a few minutes before adding the custard mixture and returning to the oven for 15 minutes. It came out really nicely and the deepness of the dish meant the custard mixture was more substantial.
Oh my goodness, these were delicious! The nutmeg on top absolutely made them – added that extra flavour. I really enjoyed them, expect next time I’ll have to make my own pastry so I can fit more of the egg custard in, because while they tasted lovely, it was mainly the tart case flavour with a little egg custard and nutmeg, instead of the other way around. The puff pastry tart came out nicely too:
They were just so yummy and home-made, not like the watery mass-produced tarts you buy at the supermarkets. Phill asked why mine weren’t as yellow as the ones in the store and I thought perhaps they add a colour to make theirs look more appealing? Either way, mine were better hands-down (and that’s saying something, since I’m not the world’s most confident or capable cook!).
EGG CUSTARD TARTS
from Best Recipes (link also includes pastry recipe, which I didn’t use)Ingredients:
3 eggs, lightly beaten
1 teaspoon vanilla essence
2 tablespoons caster sugar
2 cups milkMethod:
1. Whisk eggs, vanilla and sugar in bowl until combined
2. Heat milk until hot, then quickly whisk into egg mixture
3. Pour the custard into pastry case and cook for 15 minutes (for one large tart or about 5-10 for smaller tarts)
4. Sprinkle custard with nutmeg and cook for a further 15 minutes (once again for larger tart or about 5 minutes for smaller tarts)
5. Refrigerate until cold
Enjoy!


















